The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) devised the Star Rating system to aid beneficiaries and their families in comparing the performance and quality of Medicare Advantage plans and Medicare Part D Prescription Drug Plans.
What are Medicare Star Ratings?
Medicare Star Ratings serve as a tool utilized by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) to evaluate and compare the quality and performance of Medicare Advantage (Part C) and Medicare Part D Prescription Drug Plans (Part D). These ratings offer beneficiaries a straightforward method to assess the overall quality of these plans, with a scale ranging from 1 to 5, where a 5-star rating denotes the highest plan score.
The rating scale translates as follows:
- 5-star rating: Excellent
- 4-star rating: Above Average
- 3-star rating: Average
- 2-star rating: Below Average
- 1-star rating: Poor
How are Medicare star ratings calculated?
Medicare Star Ratings undergo distinct calculations for Medicare Advantage (Part C) plans and Medicare Part D Prescription Drug (Part D) plans. The calculation methodology for each plan type is outlined below:
Medicare Advantage (Part C) Plans:
The Star Ratings for Medicare Advantage plans result from a comprehensive evaluation encompassing various performance measures across distinct categories, including:
Health Outcomes: Evaluates the plan’s support for preventive care and chronic disease management, such as screenings, tests, and vaccines.
Managing Chronic Conditions: Assesses how effectively the plan manages chronic conditions, aiding beneficiaries in maintaining their health.
Plan Responsiveness and Care: Measures how well the plan addresses members’ needs and provides appropriate care.
Member Experience: Assesses beneficiary satisfaction with the plan’s services, including customer service, access to care, and communication.
Customer Service: Evaluates the plan’s handling of member inquiries and prompt and accurate issue resolution.
Medicare Part D Prescription Drug (Part D) Plans:
The Star Ratings for Medicare Part D prescription drug plans are based on the evaluation of the following aspects:
Prescription Drug Coverage: Assesses the scope of prescription drugs covered by the plan, including the number of covered medications and the availability of generic alternatives.
Patient Safety: Considers measures related to the safe and appropriate use of medications, including reducing the risk of adverse drug interactions.
Prescription Drug Pricing and Accuracy: Evaluates the plan’s pricing and billing accuracy for prescription drugs.
Customer Service: Assesses the quality of customer service provided by the plan, including responsiveness to member inquiries and concerns.
CMS combines individual measures within each category to calculate an overall Star Rating for each plan. These ratings are then publicly reported, empowering beneficiaries to compare the quality and performance of different Medicare Advantage and Medicare Part D prescription drug plans and make informed decisions about their healthcare coverage options. The Star Ratings undergo annual updates to reflect the most recent plan performance data.
Inputs for Medicare Advantage Star Ratings
For Medicare plans providing health coverage, such as Medicare Advantage, each plan receives an overall summary rating based on performance across five main categories:
Staying Healthy: Plans are rated on whether members had access to preventive services to maintain their health, including physical examinations, vaccinations like flu shots, and preventive screenings.
Chronic Conditions Management: Plans are rated for care coordination and the frequency of members receiving services for long-term health conditions.
Member Experience: Plans are rated for overall satisfaction with the health plan.
Member Complaints: Plans are rated on the frequency of member complaints or plan exits, addressing issues getting needed services, and plan performance improvement from year to year.
Customer Service: Plans are rated for the quality of call center services (including TTY and interpreter services) and processing appeals and new enrollments in a timely manner.
Inputs for Medicare Part D Prescription Drug Plan Star Ratings
For stand-alone Medicare Part D Prescription Drug Plans, Medicare star ratings are based on the following criteria:
Member Experience: Assessing beneficiary satisfaction with the plan’s services, including customer service, access to care, and communication.
Member Complaints: Evaluating the number of complaints received by the plan and how well they are addressed and resolved.
Customer Service: Measuring the plan’s responsiveness to member inquiries and concerns, as well as the accuracy of provided information.
Prescription Drug Safety: Considering factors such as the accuracy of the plan’s prescription drug pricing information and how often members with specific medical conditions receive clinically recommended and safer prescription drug choices.
Prescription Drug Pricing Accuracy: Evaluating the up-to-datedness and accuracy of prescription drug pricing information on the plan’s website.
Appropriate Prescription Drugs: Reviewing the percentage of plan members who receive prescriptions for drugs with high risks of serious side effects when safer alternatives may have been available.
The overall star rating serves as a concise summary of the plan’s performance, while beneficiaries can delve into individual areas within the main categories for more detailed insights. For comprehensive information on the criteria used by Medicare for rating its plans, beneficiaries can visit Medicare.gov.
Medicare Star Ratings are shaped by various pivotal factors that gauge the quality and performance of Medicare Advantage (Part C) and Medicare Part D Prescription Drug (Part D) plans. These factors encompass an array of measures focused on beneficiary experiences, healthcare outcomes, and plan effectiveness.
Clinical Outcomes and Effectiveness of Care
Critical to Medicare Star Ratings, clinical outcomes and the effectiveness of care evaluate how well Medicare Advantage (Part C) and Medicare Part D Prescription Drug (Part D) plans manage and prevent diseases, offer timely care, and minimize readmission rates.
Patient Satisfaction and Experience
Patient satisfaction and experience are pivotal in determining Medicare Star Ratings for both Medicare Advantage (Part C) and Medicare Part D Prescription Drug (Part D) plans. These measures focus on beneficiaries’ satisfaction with healthcare services and their overall experience with the plan, including aspects like reviewing appeals decisions, health plan ratings, and customer service.
Prioritizing patient satisfaction encourages plans to provide high-quality customer service and foster positive interactions between beneficiaries and healthcare providers. Plans excelling in these areas are more likely to receive higher Star Ratings, showcasing their commitment to meeting beneficiaries’ needs and preferences.
Safety and Patient-Centeredness
Safety and patient-centeredness are fundamental components influencing Medicare Star Ratings for both Medicare Advantage (Part C) and Medicare Part D Prescription Drug (Part D) plans. These factors ensure beneficiaries’ safety and well-being and align healthcare services with their individual needs.
Factors considered include special needs plan care management, medication reconciliation post-discharge, and efforts to reduce the risk of falling. Plans prioritizing evidence-based care, infection control, and medication safety are more likely to achieve higher Star Ratings, demonstrating a commitment to delivering safe and patient-centered healthcare services.
Importance of Medicare Star Ratings
Medicare Star Ratings are indispensable, serving as a guide for beneficiaries, influencing provider reimbursement and contracts, and propelling quality improvement initiatives in Medicare Advantage and Medicare Part D prescription drug plans. These ratings foster transparency, accountability, and improved healthcare outcomes for beneficiaries.
How to Find a Medicare 5-Star Rated Plan
Locating a Medicare 5-star rated plan involves using the Medicare Plan Finder tool, ensuring personalized results based on location and prescription needs. Steps include entering ZIP code and medications, selecting coverage preferences, filtering by Star Ratings, reviewing plan details, comparing costs and benefits, checking for additional benefits, and exploring beneficiary reviews.
How to Enroll in a Medicare 5-Star Rated Plan
Medicare Annual Enrollment Period (AEP)
Enroll in a 5-star rated Medicare Advantage or Medicare Part D Prescription Drug Plan during the annual Medicare Annual Enrollment Period, occurring from October 15 to December 7.
Special Enrollment Period (SEP)
If your existing Medicare plan lacks a 5-star rating, you have the opportunity to switch to a Medicare 5-star rated plan within your service area once during the 5-Star Special Election Period (SEP), running from December 8 to November 30. This option is available only if you recently switched Medicare Advantage plans during the AEP, and it can be utilized the following year.
When opting to transition from your current Medicare Advantage plan to a 5-star rated plan, ensure that the chosen plan includes prescription drug coverage if needed. Failure to do so may result in a late-enrollment penalty if you decide to add prescription drug coverage at a later date.
Ready to start a plan? Call us (971) 233-3637. Our assistance is at no cost to you.